What makes an economic damages expert report solid?

There is a sentence in Colombia's General Code of Procedure that has invalidated more expert reports than any calculation error:
"If the summoned expert does not attend the hearing, the report shall have no value" (Law 1564 of 2012, art. 228).
It doesn't say it loses weight. It says it has no value. All the technical work disappears from the case because the expert wasn't there to defend it.
First: the damage must be certain, not probable
Actual damages are what left your assets; lost profits, the gain you failed to receive (Civil Code, arts. 1613 and 1614). Both must be certain.
The Supreme Court has been consistent: lost profits require a real, tangible existence, not a merely hypothetical one (Supreme Court of Justice, 2017). In a recent ruling it required proof of a certain, current and quantifiable loss, and rejected doubtful conclusions about profits not obtained (Supreme Court of Justice, 2023).
Practical consequence: an expert report built on optimistic projections won't support a judgment, however well presented it is.
Second: the requirements almost no one meets in full
Article 226 requires the report to be clear, precise, thorough and detailed, and sets a minimum content of ten points. The most often neglected:
Documented qualifications. Degrees and certificates of experience attached.
List of cases from the last four years, with court, parties, attorneys and subject matter.
Previous appointments by the same party or the same attorney. It exists to measure the expert's independence, and the opposing party will use it.
Methodological consistency. If the method differs from the one used before, it must be justified.
Do you need to support or rebut an economic damages claim? Discover our economic damages quantification service.
Third: the hearing, where it's won or lost
The opposing party can request that the expert appear, submit another report, or both. The expert can only be excused once, and there is no special objection procedure for serious error: the rebuttal takes place there, live.
Article 232 sums up what makes an expert report solid. The judge assesses the soundness, clarity, thoroughness, precision and quality of its grounds, the expert's qualifications and their conduct at the hearing.
Note the last two criteria. They don't depend on the document, but on the person.
Who can submit it in Colombia?
Law 1673 of 2013 creates the Open Register of Valuers and provides that the role of expert be entrusted to a registered valuer when the report involves valuation matters. Its regulatory decree includes a category that mentions actual damages and lost profits (Decree 556 of 2014, art. 5).
A necessary nuance: the General Code of Procedure doesn't make admissibility conditional on any register; it requires proven qualifications and experience. The prudent course is to have an expert who meets both standards.
Frequently asked questions about economic damages expert reports
What is the difference between actual damages and lost profits?
Actual damages are the loss suffered; lost profits, the gain that was not received. Both must be proven with certainty, and each is quantified with a different methodology.
Can the opposing party submit its own report?
Yes, within the transfer period or the three days following notification. It can also request that the expert appear, or both.
What if the case is against the State?
Before the administrative courts, articles 219 and 220 of the CPACA apply first, with particularities such as challenging the expert (Law 1437 of 2011). The General Code of Procedure applies on a supplementary basis.
The report is won before the hearing
A solid expert report meets three conditions at once: it quantifies a certain damage, documents methodology and sources in the detail the law requires, and has an expert able to defend it under cross-examination.
When one of the three fails, the result is not a weaker report. It is usually a report with no value. And at that point, there is rarely a chance to fix it.
An expert report is defended at the hearing, not just on paper. At SMARKEC S.A.S. we provide economic damages quantification with support in defending the report. Book a free 30-minute consultation.
Transparency note
This content was developed by César Augusto Palomino Rubio, with the support of generative artificial intelligence as a tool to structure ideas, improve the writing and strengthen the clarity of the message. The approach, the review and responsibility for the final content belong to the author.
References
Civil Code [CC]. (1887). Law 57 of 1887, arts. 1613-1614. Official Journal No. 7,019. https://cancilleria.gov.co/sites/default/files/Normograma/docs/codigo_civil_pr049.htm
Supreme Court of Justice, Civil Cassation Chamber. (2017, April 21). Ruling SC5474-2017 (File 05001-31-03-001-2009-00128-01). https://cortesuprema.gov.co/corte/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/SC5474-2017-.pdf
Supreme Court of Justice, Civil Cassation Chamber. (2023, December 15). Ruling SC497-2023 (File 05001-31-03-013-2014-01352-01). https://cortesuprema.gov.co/corte/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/SC497-2023-2014-01352-01.pdf
Decree 556 of 2014. (2014, March 14). Regulating Law 1673 of 2013. Official Journal No. 49,092. https://jurinfo.jep.gov.co/Normograma/Compilacion/docs/decreto_0556_2014.htm
Law 1437 of 2011. Code of Administrative Procedure and Administrative Litigation. https://normativa.colpensiones.gov.co/colpens/docs/ley_1437_2011_pr005.htm
Law 1564 of 2012. (2012, July 12). General Code of Procedure. Official Journal No. 48,489. https://www.funcionpublica.gov.co/eva/gestornormativo/norma.php?i=48425
Law 1673 of 2013. (2013, July 19). Regulating the activity of valuers. Official Journal No. 48,856. https://jurinfo.jep.gov.co/Normograma/Compilacion/docs/ley_1673_2013.htm
.png)


Comments